Our practice
Representation in Criminal & Administrative Investigations
Counsel for subjects, witnesses, and organizations in federal criminal, administrative, and Inspector General investigations.
Being contacted by an investigator is never routine. Whether you are the subject of an investigation or simply a witness, speak with an attorney before you meet with an investigator or Special Agent. The need for counsel is obvious when a matter is criminal, but individuals and organizations should be just as careful with administrative investigations. It is not uncommon for an inquiry that begins as an administrative matter to uncover issues that implicate federal criminal law, and a person who believes they are cooperating as a witness can quickly find their status changed to “subject” or even “target.”
Compass Rose Legal Group represents individuals and organizations in investigations conducted by federal agencies, Offices of Inspector General, the Department of Justice, and other investigative bodies. Our goal is to protect our clients’ rights and interests at every stage—from the first contact by an investigator through any interview, referral, or resulting proceeding.
Who We Represent
- Current and former federal employees, contractors, and military members who are subjects of, or witnesses in, agency or Inspector General investigations
- Individuals contacted by the FBI or other federal law enforcement agencies, or who have received a subpoena or target letter
- Security clearance holders whose investigations may affect their eligibility for access to classified information
- Organizations and their officers and employees responding to government inquiries
- Witnesses and subjects in Office of Professional Responsibility and other internal agency inquiries
Witness, Subject, or Target
Federal prosecutors generally distinguish among three categories of people in an investigation. A witness has information about the matter under investigation. A subject is a person whose conduct falls within the scope of the investigation. A target is a person whom prosecutors or a grand jury have substantial evidence linking to the commission of a crime and who is likely to be charged. These designations are not fixed; they can change as an investigation develops—sometimes based on what a person says in an interview. Understanding where you stand, and how that may change, is one of the first things counsel can help you assess.
Administrative Interviews and Compelled Statements
Federal employees are often required to cooperate with administrative investigations, and refusing to answer questions can itself lead to discipline. The rules that govern these interviews are technical but important. Under Garrity v. New Jersey, statements an employee is compelled to make under threat of discipline generally cannot be used against that employee in a criminal prosecution. Under Kalkines v. United States, a federal employee may be required to answer questions in an administrative inquiry when assured that the answers, and their fruits, will not be used in a criminal case. Employees in bargaining units may also have the right to union representation in certain investigatory interviews.
Whether a particular interview is voluntary or compelled—and which warnings, if any, apply—can significantly affect an employee’s rights and exposure. False statements to federal investigators can also carry independent criminal liability under 18 U.S.C. § 1001, even when the underlying matter is administrative. We help clients understand the nature of an interview before it begins, prepare for it, and, where appropriate, attend it with them.
Parallel Proceedings
A single set of facts can give rise to an administrative investigation, a criminal referral, a security clearance review, and a federal employment action—sometimes all at once. What a person says in one proceeding can affect the others. We advise clients with all of these consequences in mind, so that a decision made in one forum does not create problems in another.
How We Help
- Assessing a client’s status and potential exposure early in an investigation
- Communicating with investigators, Inspectors General, and prosecutors on a client’s behalf
- Preparing clients for interviews and attending interviews with them
- Advising on compelled and voluntary statements, including Garrity and Kalkines warnings
- Responding to subpoenas, document requests, and target letters
- Negotiating the terms of proffers and other cooperation
- Preparing written submissions and responses to investigative findings
- Coordinating the defense of related security clearance and employment matters
- Conducting independent internal investigations for organizations
Experience on Both Sides of the Table
The firm’s Founding & Managing Partner, Andrew P. Bakaj, conducted, led, and managed criminal and administrative investigations. In addition to practicing law, Mr. Bakaj is trained as a Special Agent by the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center in Glynco, Georgia.
Senior Partner I. Charles McCullough III brings nearly three decades of federal service as an investigator, prosecutor, and Inspector General. He began his career with a decade at the FBI as a Special Agent, Supervisory Special Agent, Associate Division Counsel, and Special Assistant United States Attorney, conducting investigations in New York, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and Washington, D.C., including the investigation of the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing. He then served for eight years as Assistant Inspector General for Investigations in the National Security Agency Office of Inspector General, overseeing investigations and special inquiries into allegations of fraud, ethics violations, whistleblower reprisal, and the misuse of intelligence collection authorities. In 2011, the Senate confirmed him as the first Inspector General of the Intelligence Community, a position he held until 2017.
Because our attorneys have conducted, led, and overseen federal investigations themselves, we understand investigative tactics and what investigators and Special Agents can and cannot do—and we advise our clients accordingly.
If you have been contacted by an investigator, or believe you may become part of an investigation, speak with counsel before you respond. To discuss your matter, contact Compass Rose Legal Group.
